Bad Psychologists: Red Flags, Risks, and How to Protect Your Mental Health
Written by: Therapy Near Me Editorial Team Clinically reviewed by: qualified members of the Therapy Near Me clinical team Last updated: 07/09/2025 This article is intended as general information only and does not replace personalised medical or mental health advice. Learn more about our Editorial Policy. Introduction When people seek therapy, they are often in vulnerable situations—struggling with anxiety, depression, trauma, or life stressors. The right psychologist can be life-changing. But what happens if the psychologist is ineffective, unethical, or even harmful? Research shows that not all therapy is beneficial: between 5–10% of clients deteriorate during psychological treatment, often due to poor therapeutic relationships or inappropriate methods (Lambert, 2013; Lilienfeld, 2007). These cases are sometimes attributed to what clients call “bad psychologists.” This article explores what makes a psychologist “bad,” the consequences for mental health, and how to choose a qualified, ethical professional. 1. What do we mean by “bad psychologists”? A “bad psychologist” does not necessarily mean someone who is malicious. Instead, it can refer to: 2. Common red flags of a bad psychologist a) Lack of professionalism b) Breaches of ethics c) Pseudoscience and harmful techniques Some psychologists use interventions unsupported—or even contradicted—by research. Examples include rebirthing therapies (linked to child deaths; Lilienfeld, 2007) which is associated with long-term harm (APA, 2009). d) Poor therapeutic alliance The therapeutic relationship is one of the strongest predictors of success (Wampold, 2015). If the psychologist is dismissive, judgmental, or invalidating, progress is unlikely. e) Ignoring evidence-based practice Modern psychology emphasises evidence-based treatment (EBT), such as CBT, ACT, or EMDR for trauma. If a psychologist rejects proven approaches without rationale, it may be a red flag. 3. Risks of working with a bad psychologist Psychological risks Ethical and legal risks 4. How to protect yourself from bad psychologists a) Check qualifications In Australia, psychologists must be registered with AHPRA (Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency). Similar boards exist in other countries. Clients can search registries to confirm credentials. b) Look for evidence-based practice Ask: “What treatment do you use, and what evidence supports it?” Psychologists should be able to reference clinical guidelines (e.g., NICE, APA). c) Monitor progress Research supports using routine outcome monitoring to track symptom change. If progress stalls for several months, consider raising concerns (Lambert, 2013). d) Trust your instincts If you feel consistently invalidated, judged, or unsafe, it’s appropriate to seek another therapist. Therapy should be collaborative, not coercive. e) Report misconduct Professional bodies (e.g., AHPRA, APA) have complaint mechanisms for breaches of ethics. 5. Why good psychologists matter FAQs Q: What makes a psychologist “bad”?Unethical behaviour, poor professionalism, ineffective methods, or a mismatch in communication style. Q: Can therapy make you worse?Yes. Research suggests up to 10% of clients deteriorate in therapy, often due to poor therapeutic relationships or harmful methods. Q: How do I avoid a bad psychologist?Check registration, look for evidence-based treatments, and pay attention to whether you feel respected and supported. Q: Can I change psychologists if I’m unhappy?Absolutely. You have the right to change therapists if you feel the relationship isn’t working. References
Bad Psychologists: Red Flags, Risks, and How to Protect Your Mental Health Read More »













